Pretoria, Are You Listening? Elephants Belong in the Wild!

Besides the obvious public safety concerns, the industry is thus fraught with numerous animal welfare concerns, which seem to fall on deaf ears when brought to the attention of the conservation officials.

What is it going to take for conservation authorities in South Africa to take a stand against the irresponsible practice of keeping elephants in captivity for “captive tourism” purposes? On Saturday, an elephant handler at the Knysna Elephant Park was mauled by an adult bull elephant. This is not the first time this elephant has been involved in such an attack, previously killing another elephant handler. Luckily, Mr. Melikhaya Ndzwanana survived the ordeal but he is in a critical state in a private hospital in Knysna and has had to have one of his legs amputated.

The business of keeping elephants in captive environments for “tourism” purposes had become increasingly popular in South Africa and before conservation authorities had a chance to mutter “um”, a number of venues around the country were offering elephant-back ride and/or elephant-walk safari experiences.

And then, to make matters worse, some NGO’s, including the International Fund for Animal Welfare, created a right fuss around the practice of removing juvenile elephants from wild family groups to supply demand for the growing industry, a practice deemed totally unethical by most people who know a thing or two about elephants and their complex social structures.

Pretoria, we have a problem.

Well, the good news is that the aforementioned practice of removing elephants from the wild for lives in captivity was banned through the promulgation of the National Norms and Standards for the Management of Elephants in South Africa.

This was an extremely positive development in that it put a brake on the proliferation of the industry. However, a number of elephants remain in various captive facilities around the country and, while some of us had hoped that the industry would be phased out over time, there is no law banning the breeding of elephants in these facilities.

To make matters worse, there are no appropriate laws governing the keeping and “taming” of elephants in captive environments in South Africa. Besides the obvious public safety concerns, the industry is thus fraught with numerous animal welfare concerns, which seem to fall on deaf ears when brought to the attention of the conservation officials.

In fact, because the industry has no conservation value, conservation officials have tried to palm it off to other departments claiming they have no role to play where animal welfare standards are concerned.

At the end of the day, however, someone in power needs to take ownership and work to responsibly phase out these dangerous and unethical practices, unless we want to be known as a country that has little respect for public safety in tourism and no regard for animal welfare.

Elephants belong in the wild, not in captivity.

-- JBL

For more information on the International Fund for Animal Welfare effort to save elephants around the world visit

Comments: 2

7 years ago

When will humans learn & stop interfering with Wild life, Elephants do belong in the Wild with their families, & South Africa should have LAWS for Elephants & other Wildlife to stop Exploitation by Humans who are only doing it to make Money, this is the 21st Century havent you learnt anything,

7 years ago

Yes! elefants to belong in the wild...Your country should be admired for its kindness and respect of wildlife..
"The greatnes of a country is measured by the way it treats its animals"

Post a comment


Vice President, Hoofd Internationale Activiteiten en Programma's
President en Algemeen Directeur
Beth Allgood, Directeur Verenigde Staten
Directeur Verenigde Staten
Senior adviseur beleidsontwikkeling
Senior adviseur beleidsontwikkeling
Dr. Maria (Masha) N. Vorontsova, Regiodirecteur Rusland en GOS
Regiodirecteur Rusland en GOS
Faye Cuevas, Esq.
Senior Vice President
Grace Ge Gabriel, Regiodirecteur Azië
Regiodirecteur Azië
Vicepresident Natuurbehoud en Dierenwelzijn
Vicepresident Natuurbehoud en Dierenwelzijn
Jason Bell, Vice President for Conservation and Animal Welfare
Vice President for Conservation and Animal Welfare
Jeffrey Flocken, Regiodirecteur Noord-Amerika
Regiodirecteur Noord-Amerika
Matt Collis, Director, International Policy
Director, International Policy
Patrick Ramage, Hoofd Programma Oceaanbescherming
Hoofd Programma Oceaanbescherming
Peter LaFontaine, Manager Campagnes, IFAW Washington, D.C.
Manager Campagnes, IFAW Washington, D.C.
Sonja Van Tichelen
Vice President Internationale Bedrijfsvoering
Tania McCrea-Steele, Internationaal Projectleider Wildlife Crime
Internationaal Projectleider Wildlife Crime